This data is referenced heavily in chapter 2 of my book Theatres of Value. Here, I am attaching the dataset in full in the hopes that it will be more useful to others in this form. I compiled the Barnum database over the course of several years using the following sources:
Documents found at the Harvard Theatre Collection in Cambridge, MA.
Documents found at the American Antiquarian Society in Worcester, MA.
Documents found at the Bridgeport History Center in Bridgeport, CT.
George C. Odell's Annals of the New York Stage
T. Allston Brown's History of the New York Stage
Joseph Ireland's Records of the New York Stage, from 1750 - 1860
Please cite this data as: Rosvally, Danielle. "Barnum Database." Theatres of Value: Buying and Selling Shakespeare in Nineteenth-Century New York City. New York: State University of New York Press, ACCESS DATE. https://www.daniellerosvally.com/publications/barnumdb.